Stephenie Meyer was on the latest Mugglecast (A Harry Potter podcast from mugglenet.com) were Stephenie talks about the differences and similarities between Twilight and HP, and who would win in a fight- Edward of Harry?
Haha you can download it HERE.
edward would win. edward would be to fast for harry to say anything.
edward would be too fast. harry wouldn’t have a prayer. *sobs* i love harry!
Edward all the way baby!!..haha
Steph is hilarious..love the woman to death.
Yea and Edward would be able to see Harry’s moves before Harry even did them because he can read minds. That settles it. haha =]
Edward would win DUH. there are too many things in his favor to have him NOT win.
YES!!! FINALLY! the meaning to the cover!! about time!! <33
i loved the last scene too!! <3
Renee
pffffft
edward would definatly win
he’s immortal
harrys’ mortal
Good point spidermonkey! haha
well, harry does have a wand…
but edward’s a god… so i think eds would win =]]
Dude Edward would totally own Harry:
1. Hes faster
2. He can read minds
3. He isn’t a mortal (and Harry is)
4. And he can just dazzle people into helping him
lol
I LOVE EDWARD : D
(also love Harry(sorry)) lol
lol i love mugglecast! i cant wait to download it!
Ummm, Well I think it would be a tie. I mean Harry beat voldemort!!! But then Edward is amazing and immortal… They would eventually give up and shake on it!
EDWARD!!
duhh, harry’s gonna be all like “EXPECTO-PATRONUM!!”
but by that time edward already has his teeth
in his skin. + i dont think any one of harry’s spells
would kill edward, unless that spell can rip off
all of edwards body parts and then burn them.
& edward is a man, harry, hes just a boy…who lived,
but look at ron, hes a boy, and hes living. geeze.
Saying Harry would win in a fight against Edward is like saying Bella will choose Tyler – not a chance!
1. The only way to kill a vampire is to shred and burn them and there is no spell for that
2. Edward would have ripped off Harry’s head before he even opened his mouth
3. Edward can move as fast as a spell
4. Edward can hear Harry’s thoughts
5. The spells would just bounce off Edward’s stone skin
Team Edward! I like harry to so long as he leaves Edward alone. Edward wouldn’t start a fight without a good reason, and if Harry tried I would dance on his fictional grave!
Once Edward was done with him!
WOW!! What kind of question is that?!? OF COURSE Edward would win!
ha. i like melissas point
& so does rapunzuel bwha.
what if harry had a spell that could block his thoughts from reaching edward?
maggie. so hes a freaking vampire! hes too fast for spells! and if harry had some sorta spell like that alice could be seeing what harry would do and edward would just be reading her mind! so ha. :p edward rules.
I was just looking on Mugglenet and the comments are awful!!! Some of them are calling Stephanie Meyer “that woman” and Twilight “absolutely terrible”. And of course Edward would win!!! Immortal, super-strong, brilliant eyesight, mind-reading and if that didn’t save Edward, Bella’s shield could. Go Edward!!!! And Twilight!!!
Edward wouldn’t win. Harry would use Avada Kedavra, the killing curse. Although, it might not work as effectively as on a human. Hmmm… *JKR Question right there* And Bella’s shield doesn’t protect from wands. Vampire spells.
By the way, I am anti-Twilight. I needed a place to post sense :}