The WinnipegFreePress has a review of Breaking Dawn here. *SPOILERS*
The Willamette Weekly has another Breaking Dawn “Review” here.
19 thoughts on “Even More Breaking Dawn Reviews”
xXJasperXx
you know what? shes the one whos ‘batshit crazy.’ just because breaking dawn wasnt what people expected doesnt mean it deserves to be dissed and hated.
i dont get the The Willamette Weekly review, do they like it or not? anyway i cant find the winnipeg one on the link but i havent read many reviews cuase when u read a bad one it can spoiler it u know? like after bella and edwards 1st time, she was all happy and he was all down and agery
yeah so whatta u guyz think?
yeah…read before you judge. Or @least TRY to grasp the concept ofwhat you’re reading. The problem with reviews is they only give one persons oppinion…so half the people who read it get really mad,and the other half say even more horrible things about it …which makes the first half angrier…etc etc etc. Or people whove never read it put too much faith in these jerks oppinions. Reviews shouldnt exist..people need to just go buy the book themselves.
yeah…it seems like they just have one reviewer for each magazine…and they give them random books that just came out every month. They seem to do that with movies too. Thats actually a really good idea…give the person in each catagory what they know so they cant bash what they dont.
I think, That all 4 book are a great achivement and should be rewarded
i mean At my school there is a craze for These books, all the girls and some of the boys are obsessing about these books.
people who think that these book deserve to be dissed need a padded cell because there not right in the head.
I liked the book, though it wasn’t what I had expected. I mean there are flaws to the storyline and the ending is just slightly too happy but in the end it’s just a book, a nice book that was nice and fun to read and to reread as well. I liked the other books a lot better but still it was good in its own way giving an end to the series. It could have been better but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t enjoyable and it certainly didn’t deserve to be dissed like that. one can note the flaws and what ever else is bothering them but shouldn’t take it too seriously: it’s just a book.
you know what? shes the one whos ‘batshit crazy.’ just because breaking dawn wasnt what people expected doesnt mean it deserves to be dissed and hated.
i dont get the The Willamette Weekly review, do they like it or not? anyway i cant find the winnipeg one on the link but i havent read many reviews cuase when u read a bad one it can spoiler it u know? like after bella and edwards 1st time, she was all happy and he was all down and agery
yeah so whatta u guyz think?
That Willamette Weekly one has me confuzzled!
Sorry I linked the Willamette Weekly one wrong, but I fixed it, so if you click now it will take you to the review. =]
UGH! THAT WILLAMETTE THING HAS ME SOO MAD! IT WAS A GREAT BOOK!. gah. stupid reviewers.
I agree with you Elizabeth
The things that is being said in amazon is just plain hurtful…SM doesn’t deserve the hate that she’s getting.
BD IS a great book, no matter what those other selfish people say.
exactly! thank you aven! they are just don’t like it because they dont like how the book turned out because it wasn’t what they were expecting.
the WinnipegFreePress seemed to give it a good review or so it seemed , whatever i oved it anyway
Ha ha I’m from Winnipeg lmao, good review…lol
okay seriously dont bash out on the books if you know little of it, get your facts straight and then give a good review
i doubt the reviewers even read twilight, new moon and eclipse
same here.
yeah…read before you judge. Or @least TRY to grasp the concept ofwhat you’re reading. The problem with reviews is they only give one persons oppinion…so half the people who read it get really mad,and the other half say even more horrible things about it …which makes the first half angrier…etc etc etc. Or people whove never read it put too much faith in these jerks oppinions. Reviews shouldnt exist..people need to just go buy the book themselves.
agreed lori.
i think that there should be like reviewers but like one reviewer for like umm young adult fantasy books..etc. does that make sense?
yeah…it seems like they just have one reviewer for each magazine…and they give them random books that just came out every month. They seem to do that with movies too. Thats actually a really good idea…give the person in each catagory what they know so they cant bash what they dont.
I think, That all 4 book are a great achivement and should be rewarded
i mean At my school there is a craze for These books, all the girls and some of the boys are obsessing about these books.
people who think that these book deserve to be dissed need a padded cell because there not right in the head.
agreed chloe, but you cant forget the straight jacket
I liked the book, though it wasn’t what I had expected. I mean there are flaws to the storyline and the ending is just slightly too happy but in the end it’s just a book, a nice book that was nice and fun to read and to reread as well. I liked the other books a lot better but still it was good in its own way giving an end to the series. It could have been better but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t enjoyable and it certainly didn’t deserve to be dissed like that. one can note the flaws and what ever else is bothering them but shouldn’t take it too seriously: it’s just a book.