TIME magazine has put up their review for Breaking Dawn! Click here to see it.
“It’s a wild but satisfying finish to the ballad of Bella and Edward..”
Grade: A-
Twilighters
The twilight fansite – evolved.
TIME magazine has put up their review for Breaking Dawn! Click here to see it.
“It’s a wild but satisfying finish to the ballad of Bella and Edward..”
Grade: A-
It’s a hell of a lot better than a freakin “D”. yay TIME!
totally agree!
you should read the stranger’s review (a small seattle paper) it’s hillarious.
http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/Content?oid=638178&hp
I would have liked an A+ better, but at least they read the book, unlike the people that reviewed for Entertainment Weekly!
yay an A i would have given it like an A+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ but i dont work for them
lol and i like what they said about sex with a vampire cause we all wanted to ask lol jk
but i agree!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I have to agree with Edwardlover, the person that reviewed for EW probably just went to amazon and saw the first comment there and wrote pretty much the same.
Izzy an A is an A wether it is minus or plus..haha
That’s great.. finally someone who knows how to actually write a proper review.
finally! at least someone finally has a good reviewer. i would have said A++ but hey, any A will do.
I totally agree with everyone here…finally somebody puts up a good review, I would have also like to see it get an A+ but hey, an A- is better then anything. this makes me happy, all the haters out there were beginning to piss me off.
WOOT! go TIME! i give it an A++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ but critics they cant give anything a perfect score!
omgsh i love Time
i agree with y’all, like no joke, the haters and ridiculously stupid articles or ‘reviews’ were pissing me offffffff!
of course, i would give breaking dawn an A+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
but that’s just me
way to go Time!
Woohoo!! Nice job Time!! Of course, like everyone else, I would give BD an A+!!!
Breaking Dawn deserves more!
It is good to see reviewers from large magazines recognize the awesomeness of Breaking Dawn
hey miao ru, its like izzy said, an a is an a wether its a minus or a plus. TIME IS AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!! they have a sane reviewer!!
FINALLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! SOMEONE WHO ACTUALLY LIKED IT!!!!!!!!!!!!
yeah. someone who actually liked it….but gave it the shortest and most undescriptive review i’ve seen so far. i don’t really agree with the rating either. i give it a C+. sorry, but the first three were waaaaaay better.
XXJASPERXX, haha yup that’s how i see it.
TIME has an actual reviewer i=on their payroll, all of the other publications and sites..please take notes..lol
yay! But totally A++++++
Woo Hoo!! Go Times!! I’m so happy that SOMEONE finally notices that the True Fans really loved it. It was making me so mad that no one was paying attention to us (the ones that found the meaning and love in it).. and only to the ones bashing Stephenie. She is totally awesome..!! I hope she can finally hear us. We Love you Stephenie!!
Oh and I was one of the ones that wanted to ask about..you know..lol me and my friends had a long conversation about that. LOL I love when she asked “why did you bite the pillows?”
I love Edward
I love Edward
I love Edward
I love Edward
I love Edward
I love Edward
I love Edward
I am Team Switz
I love Jacob
I love Jacob
I love Jacob
I love Jacob
I love Jacob
I love Jacob
I love Jacob
<3
Lots of luv
-Marianne
Finally someone who reads the book and reviews not those stupid EW people you gave them a D. GO TIME…AND TWILIGHT NEW MOON ECLIPSE BREAKING DAWN EDWARD BELLA RENESMEE JACOB CARLISLE ESME JASPER EMMETT ROSALIE ALICE TANYA ZAFRINA..AND..a LOT more, oh and CHARLIE =>
Wow, A-? Thats crazy that thats so different from the entertainment weekly review!
SWEET!! I would totally take that!! Yay TIMES!!
i loved this book. but i hated jacob. and im in luv wit carisle he is so hot. and like evry1 say bd desrves an a++++++++
yay times! finally a good review… well more like a good reviewer! yay! this should lift up stephs spirits. a great review
Woot! SOME people actually know what they’re talking about.
I liked it, even though it was very short.
Okay call me weird, after reading most of the book (still haven’t got it done, but I’m over halfway done) — guess I’m a slow reader lol. I actually like Edward and Jacob (used to not like Jacob at all now I guess you could say I tolerate him haha). *I know that was pointless* Anyway from what I have read I would’ve gave it a A+++++, oh well.. guess a A- will do. :p
its so much better than an a- it should get an a+
JASPER ROCKS
I LOVE JASPER
HOLA PEOPLES HEY MRC VAMP i want to say that i agree you can at least tolerate him. I still love the books though!!
YEAH! Entertainment is full of BS!!! a D? maybe they should get different journalists because jennifer reese/kate ward obviously doesnt like the series at all. NO RESPECT! I think people shouldnt rate these books because it’s one whole story, so to break them down separately from each other is almost disresectful to the world Stephanie Meyer created. anyone agree? If you didnt like the ending then thats too bad. It’s her story/world and we should respect that. We are just here for the ride!!! TEAM STEPHENIE!
A-…
oh well at least they reviewed it.
That’s so true even though i wouldn’t mind reading a lot more about it
TIME i love you!!!!!!!! this article actually makes sense! lol no D’s