wtf?? both of these would be tragic

neither! i dont want either of them!

first yay

alright. i don’t really like any of them honestly.
and vanessa i REALLY don’t want as a vampire.
NEITHER.

omg!!! nether… they’re disney.. and vanessa isn’t beautiful enough.. hahaha but really they should find someone else..

i prefer brenda over vanessa, but i think vanessa could play a good emily or leah…
but not a vampire because i dont think she fits the description of any of the volturi memebers.

i don’t like neither of them
NO disney stars!!!!
*ugh* im sick of them!

EWWWWWWW that is so gross if either of them are in the film it will suffer the rath of millions of teenage girls. I hate Vanessa and Brenda is good but not for this movie.

ew. why would either of them be picked.
they are like disney trademark actors.
this is not high school musical.
and this is not the suite life.
no.
no no no.
ugh.

Brenda song? u have got to be kidding! just cause you have dark hair dose not make you look native!!! SHE’S extremely noticeably Asian! and Huggins could not handle the depth of a conflicted character that doesn’t break into song! really… honestly… i know for a fact that actors of the native population are not such an endangered species… lets have a Louis and Clark movie where Sacajawea is played by a brunette paris hillton!

I’m sorry. But Disney stars should just not be allowed in Twilight. Disney stars stay with Disney. It’ll save everybody the panic attack.

oh noes! that would totally kill New Moon D:

Are they joking?? Leah Clearwater needs to be kick-ass. She is a werewolf? Do you think werewolf when you look at Vanessa Hudges? I’m not sure if it’s a coincidence that both of the candidates are really girly and annoying and have perky voices–either they tragically messed up or whoever’s casting needs to talk to Stephenie about characterization. I mean, VANESSA HUDGES??

wtf???????????????????????????
ok vanessa should stick wit high school musical
i dont enen kno wat brenda does
neither of them should do that role
i cant enen imagine vanessa as a vampire or a warewolf
it would ruined the movie
im being honest
they should pick someone that looks more native like ummmm idk but they should find someone else
>:(

neither one really look Native American. I just hope whomever they get they are good actors because that is what made the first film good.

ew. please no.
neither of them are good enough for this movie. i really don’t think disney stars would be fit for any of the roles.

The actress who will play Leah needs to be STRONG, and independent, and reeeeeally good! Brenda and Vanessa both have the ‘girl next door’ look going for them, but that wouldn’t work for Leah. But I TOTALY thnk Vanessa Hudgens would be great to play Emily Young.

i really love Twilight and all of the actors in it. and i dont think that some Disney people would fit in a movie like this one. I cant even imagine someone like that im mean really a Teen Star that plays in kiddie movie uh NO! some one more saficated. Please Dont Ruin The Movie With Them!!

If Vanessa plays Leah it will make for a bad movie. Please no Disney stars in Twilight! None of them are even remotely good actors/actresses.
Whoever is casting needs to read the books and see what the characters are like and confer with Stephanie about who gets cast. I really hope that they aren’t just trying to bring in a Disney star to try to get some of the Disney following, because that would absolutely KILL the movie if they did that.

HELL no! No disney stars!!! I think that Valerie Poxlienter- (That singer named Lights) would be a good leah.

i’d want q’orianka kilcher as emily.

HECK NO.
I SWEAR THEY BETTER NOT BRING ANY FRICKIN DISNEY IDIOT STARS INTO THIS!!UGH

please no disney stars!!! i mean come on people!!!

I really hope they don’t bring disney stars into the AMAZING Twilight movies. That would totally suck! Disney stars need to stay with disney! That would ruin New Moon.

NO ONE OF THEM SHOULD BE IN THIS MOVIE !!!
I SWEAR IF I SEE THEM IN IT , I WILL HAVE GO INSANE !
WAYYY TO PERKY TO PLAY THE PART OF A HEARTBROKEN CHARACTER ! THEY JUST DONT FIIIT ! THERE A SO MANY BETTER PEOPLE TO MAKE THIS PART ! & IF I SEE LIL MISS VANNESA HUDGENS AS A VAMPIRE, I WILL HAVE A TALK WITH THE PEOPLE WHO MADE TWILIGHT !
&IF TAYLOR ISN’T IN THIS BECAUSE OF HIS SIZE(which i think he actually did make the part again) BUT THEY DO GET IT , THAT IS TOTALLY NOOOOOT FAIR !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!>:o
DO . NOT . PUT . THEM . IN . THAT . PART !!!!!

WHAT?! i don’t want a washed out disney channel star working on the movies that are going to COMEPLETE MY LIFE. ahh!!

neither.. especially not vanessa

NEITHER!!!!!!!!! Do not bring ANY disney stars in this!!!!!!!!!! totaly neither! of all the stars in the world?!?!?!? Omg!

WTF!!!! oh heck no…i love Disney but their Disney stars CANNOT come into the Twilight movies…neither of them are even good actresses…i mean i don’t really like Leah becuz she doesn’t like Bella but i don’t want them to play her…omg no…

NO!!!No,no,no,no.no,please no. For the love of the Twilight Saga and EVERYONE in it, do not cast EITHER of them.That would piss EVERYONE OFF!!!Me of all people would know, I am A HUGE HUGE HUGE FAN! Don’t make twilght’s biggest and most devoted fans feel horrible about this!No!Just no,get someone else. Those girls are just not Leah!

Yeah rite! Disney + Twilight = don’t even go there!

i don’t like either. but didn’t taylor laurent star in a disney movie? Sharkboy and Lava girl.

Why don’t they find an actual native american girl for Leah instead of Disney stars!!!! ughhh and there are no vampires that are described anything like either of them, no insult to them as actresses, but they’re just not right!

i agree with Twilight Lover it would really suck. Neither of them really seem to fit the role of Leah at all. I think if they had to pick one of them though, I think it should be Brenda Song. I still have Vanessa Hudgens stuck as the High School Movie School star, and she will probably always seem that way. That’s just my opinion. But overall, I think Twilight and Disney should be kept seperate!

NEITHER OF THEM ARE EVEN REMOTELY CLOSE TO BEING LEAH!LEAH IS A BOSSY BUT SPUNKY GIRL THAT WILL NEVER LET ANYBODY BOSS HER AROUND.THEY LOOK LIKE IF U TURNED THEM DOWN FOR THE PART,THEY’D CRY ALL DAY!THEY LOOK TO UMMM ……INNOCENT,YOU KNOW.AND MOST OF US JUST REALLY HATE VANESSA MORE THAN THE VOTURI,EVEN THO THEY AWESOME!I LOVE ANY VAMPIRE GOOD OR BAD.

NO WAY!
EWW!
Oh but everyone should remember that Taylor was a Disney star.
I still don’t want either of them though.

OMG!!! NO NO NO WAY!!!!!!! It’ll be a DISASTER!!! A retarded Disney Movie!!!! And not to mention Brenda Song is a horrible actress (sorry)! And Vanessa is too known for her role in HSM.
It has to be serious, mature, and PG-13 at least!!!! PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE!!! I was upset when they got Shark Boy, but I got used to him. But for goodness sake, NOT THEM!!! I know Summit is too cheap to get some real proffessionals, but please….Not Disneychannel stars….please..

Neither of them. They should stick to Disney. They would just ruin the whole movie because the media is going to focus on how they are Disney stars.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! yeah rite they will make GREAT werewolves!!!! heckNOOOOO! i would prefer someone who isnt famous already, i think the producers should go on a Leah hunt.!!!!! i would totally join that hunt! anything for the pack! I LOVE U JACOB!(TAYLOR)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! u too edward(rob)….

ahhh :[ no no no,
but if you had to choose those too, i would deffintly choose brenda, not vanessa :/

i 100% agree with Melissa Cullen….

Pleeeeeeeeeease no. Twilight is not a Disney Channel movie.

No. Disney. Stars.
Why don’t they just get the jo bro’s while their at it, they can play the volturi .

Oh gawd. They better pick good for Jane and the volturi.

Neither. Please. I have nothing against them, I’ve seen them in other roles and it’s not that the’re bad actresses, but I just can’t see them playing Leah. She’s just so fierce and she always has an independent attitude. They’re just too sweet-looking to play a character like her. But I agree with Katie Cullen. Vanessa would be a good Emily.

i agree with melissa cullen!! theyre both way to short and they already took over disney they dont need to take over the twilight world too! how about vanessa stick with her damn porn and just stay away from GOOD movies!!!

OMFG noooooo!!!! neither one of them can’t be a vampire
disney stars don’t deserve to be in any of these movies!!
Iuuuuuuuuck!:/

im sorry but WTF! there is no way that either of them would be castd as leah. no offense to anyone whose a fan of vanessa or brenda but i just cant see them in any of the twilight films. theyre too… disney channel. everytime u see them u think of either zack and cody or hsm. they should just stick to disney channel.
hahaha seems lik lots of people have the same thought.
NO DISNEY CHANNEL STARS!

Ew, none. I don’t think any of them can pull off that roll. And i’m sure that people don’t want either of them to play the role of Leah.

wtf???
Vanessa Hudgens ???
I would pick Brenda but she doesnt look like leah,

Please. They put vanassa in that movie and it ruins it i hate her!! She is not native looking or tall or anything!! ugh!!

OMG NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO I AGREE WIth TRINKIE!!!!!!!!!!!! WHAT A HORRIBLE EMBARRASMENT THEY WOULD BE!!!! I WOULD JUST START LAUGHING IF THEY EVEN TRIED A MOVIE THAT WAS EVEN REMOTELY SERIOUS!!!! THEY ARE DISNEY MANUFACTORED FAKEs.

this is kinda rude but im just not a fan, they play fine characters in their select branch of movies and tv but they are not right for twilight

This will ruin the whole movie.
I picture Leah being cute, yet still kind of tomboyish. She’s totally supposed to be badass. Please let this just be a rumor.

This thing already feels tainted, The more the merrier. Why not, this movie apparently isn’t going to have passionate people portraying the characters, just hollywood cliches

I dont think either of them should be Leah.
Ewww!!!!
They shouldnt be a vampire either

Vanessa is too high school musical…
I think unheard ofs would be much better…
I really don’t want to see vanessa in it… She doesn’t look like Leah should at all!!! AND not as a vampire either.
I agree with others, no disney starts thanks!!

i have just recalled that taylor did play a disney character as chark boy. i hate to admit but i have seen this movie and it was when he was muhc younger. Vanessa and BRanda are still on the Disney seen and it is not the same. I think taylor did a fabulous portryle of jacob (a hell of a lot better than WENT STRAIGHT TO VIDEO bring on in it to win it star micheal coupon) but brenda and vanessa just arent right it simply wouldn’t work

i think hannah montana should be leah ;]

*****SHARK sorry

ARE YOU JOKING!!!!!

If either of them play the movie will be wrecked and they better not put vanessa as emily, she is too girly girly and it would be wreck!! they need someone who is beautiful, nt slutty beautiful. and i dont think any of the fans out there would wont disney stars in the movie!!
DNT USE THEM!!

none of them! god no, that would totally upset the fandom. We all have very high standards for who should play Leah, and neither of them fit the part in my opinion.

are u fucking serious ..hannah montana?!?!she is a pop brat>>freak..and no neither of them make a good leah….vannesa ughh she is weird and brenda song is not a good actress..disney stars should not be in the twilight series….please summit please read this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i will be extremely mad if vanessa does!
i’m sorry but that would ruin the whole movie for me. and brenda,, maybe i like her better than vanessa but there both disney and they don’t fit the part of leah at all.

I agree with DLO! TRAGIC!
They should stick with casting stars that are great actors and not because they look like they’d fit the part.
I guarantee this will upset Twilight fans yet again!
… we’ve seemed to always get our way in the end, right? lol

OMIFE. really?!? why them for rumors? i mean i think they can find people MUCH better because they found all the perfect people for the cullens <3 and i know there asian but they are short and i dont think they could fit the role because leah is kinda mean i guess…but they seem too goody-goody and eh..disney channel stars? ugh im already upset there thinking of changing jacob black to michael capon…ugh no! this is not good RAWR. go team edward.

Yikes. thats all i have to say…

NO DISNEY please… that is what made Twilight a well done, original movie- original casting.

omg! gross! Can’t they choose better actors and not these tiny boppers. gosh.

SHARKBOY & LAVAGIRL NOT A DISNEY MOVIE!

but Taylor did have a small role in Cheaper By the Dozen 2

NO WAY!!!!11!!!!1!!ONE!!!!!
I might have to throttle someone if either of them are in the movie….. NO DISNEY.

This girl would be awesome I think, but not sure how tall she is, Q’orianka Kilcher and then her brother is a cutie, Kainoa. He could even be Seth

neither should be in it, that would just ruin it!

Oh God if they get them to play parts in Twilight..
I know they can find way better actresses then that..!

ok, I gotta yell here… OMG! SUMMIT! TAKE CHANCES! GET NEW FACES! New Moon can bring some great actors into the spotlight! GET SOMEONE NEW and GET OUT OF DISNEY! Sorry I yelled, just had to get my point across there. ANY DISNEY CAST (Jackson isn’t disney, even though he did the 411 thing) AND I WONT GO!

oh btw, I totally agree with ‘Joanna L.’ About Q’orianka Kilcher. She would be so perfect and was amazing in The New World. Thats actually how I pictured Leah in the first place, and I never heard of Kilcher then. I VOTE FOR Q’ORIANKA KILCHER!

I really,really think that both of these actresses are a very bad idea.

NOT VENNESSA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I don’t like neither of them. Disney people are too goody-goody. People will go see the movie just because they’re in it and not because they are fans.
BUT if I had to pick between them. I’d pick Vanessa Hudgens. At least she’s part Native American. Brenda Song is asian, people, HELLO! Please stay at least a LITTLE consistant with the storyline!

one word; NO !!
vanessa hudgens is just too gabriella aka hsm.
and
brenda song is just too the suite life.

ugh. disney stars should just stay. at disney!

No…please…no Vanessa hudgens….she will ruin movie..if she played leah…and brenda song…it okay..but i don’t think she ash that lean look or style or soemthing

nooo!!! twilights cast was pretty low-key people, and i think it should stay like tht. if disney ppl or already famous ppl come in, it’ll pretty mch mess up the whole movie.
Vanessa as a vamp or leah…. EWWWWW!!! shes not fit for tht. if they have to choose btwn the 2, vanessa should be gone and brendas chinese, and leahs native american…see my case?

NO FING WAY! This isn’t a disney movie. They better not put these teen boppers in it. It would seriously ruin the movie.

WTF!!HELL NO !!Vanessa Hugens….is this some kind of sick joke..?coz it is so not funny…

NOOOOOOOOOOOOO I don’t like either of them! No, no, no please let this rumor be just that! A rumor! Vanessa will ruin the movie!

******************************!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!TAYLOR DOOLEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!************************************* idk how tall she is but she would be perfect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

NO WAY! Brenda is obviously Asian- NOT Native American! And Vannessa is wayyy 2 High School Musical! PLZ! NO DISNEY!!!!

…and they r both 5′2! Summit cant b saying Taylor (who is the PERFECT Jacob) is “too short” for the part of a werewolf and then turn around and hire one of THEM! That would b SOOOO unfair!!! Ugh! >=P

AH HELLZ NO!!!
NO WAY!
I DO NOT WANT DISNEY STARS IN ANY OF THE FILMS!!!!!!
I THINK ALL TWILIGHTERS AGREE!
THEY DO NOT FIT THE DESCRIPTION!
Maybe odette yustman from the unborn she is pretty tall and i think she would be a good leah.

(please dont totally freak out on my suggestion)

well… brenda song is a huge fan of twilight so i don’t think she’s want to ruin the movies.. but i don’t know… I kinda don’t want her to play in it..

Uggghhh !
Vanessa cant act !
She is not Native american!
She sucks at being genuine !

I think that they should hire someone who can handle a conflicting role with multiple emotional levels.
Someone like Q’orianka Kilcher maybe.

I think brenda should get it!
she’s a way better actor….and vanessa is just……UGH!
that’s the only way i can put it nicely….:/
haha

OMG! I looked up pics of Q’orianka Kilcher and she looks like she would make a really good Leah. Anything but disney channel stars!!! Please, for the love of New Moon- NO DISNEY STARS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i swear to Jesus. if any of these two become leah…oh…its going down.

UGH! neither…. i’ve rethought it…
and vanessa as a vampire?! like as in JANE?!
i DON’T THiNK SO!!!!!!
that’s absolutely NUTS!!!

I HATE VANESSA HUDGENS! she can’t act please no disney stars please i dont think i’d even be able to sit through it if she was leah.

I HONESTLY DON’T GIVE A FUCK IF THEY ARE GOOD ENOUGH TO PLAY THE ROLE OR NOT!!!!! THEY ARE DISNEY CHARACHTERS THEY HAVE GROWN UP AS DISNEY CHARACHTERS AND THEREFORE HAVE BEEN RAISED IN A CAMPY WORLD OF APPY ENDINGS…NEITHER OF THEM COULDN HANDLE THE PAIN THAT LEAH GOES THEOUGH IN THE TWILIGHT SAGA…AND HONESTLY THERE ARE ENOUGH TWILIGHT HATERS…BRING THE DISNEY STARS IN AND WE’LL HAVE 5 YEAR OLDS TAKING OUR SEATS IN THE THEARTERS AND TONS OF PPL HATING TWILIGHT BECAUSE OF THE CAMPYNESS OF THEIR ACTING…WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT NEW MOON IS GOOD SO THAT WE CAN GET THEM TO MAKE THE TRULY FANOMINAL BOOKS INTO MOVIES LIKE ECLIPSE AND BRAKING DAWN!!! THEY CAN NOT RUIN THAT FOR US!!! HELL NO!!!

That would totally kill the movie right there. Honestly, I would have second thoughts MANY TIMES about even seeing it if either of them were in the movie. I find them both kind of pathetic. They need to stick to their little kiddie Disney musicals, thank you very much. Leave the acting to the real actors.

no no no!!!!! yuck to both of them

NOT THEM.

1) Brenda song is ASIAN, not Indian

And TWO, I’ve seen Venassa’s boobies. And I’ll never be able to get that image out of my head.

If she is cast…..

Wow. Summit, you’re really starting to tick me off. Like, seriously. This may be the last straw,

NO!!!!! NEITHER OF THE THEM CAN BE CAST IN NEW MOON.. PLEASE WE NEED REAL ACTORS.. IM SURE.. NO IM ABSOLUTELY POSITIVE THAT THERE ARE BETTER ACTORS FOR THESE PARTS.

I think it would be better for Summit to spend their money hiring several good, virtually unkown actors/actresses for the roles than picking up the mainstream ones who are going to need a higher paycheck. They might as well make their small budget go as much towards CGI and other important stuff rather than cast. I think the original Twilight cast proved that big names don’t always create success for a movie.

Neither! If VH is cast I’m going to cry. Please no!

NONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONOOOOOOO. NO.

letter to summit:

Dear Summit,
If you cast ANY disney people in this movie, i will sic my army of vampire pineapples on you. Seriously.
Most sincerely (you better believe it),
Emsy.
PS If you even THINK the words “Miley Cyrus” and “Twilight saga” in the same statement, trust me, i will know, and not only will my vampire pineapples destroy you, i will also establish an angry mob–complete with torches and pitchforks–to come and destroy you. Do NOT make the mistake of thinking that i am kidding. I mean it.

btw, Hope, i completely agree with you.

Hm…I can imagine Vanessa being one of the Volturi…possibly the one that goes out to bring the food home ^.^ though her name escapes me right now.

I find this quite funny – how anyone could think that a disney ’star’ could pull off any role in New Moon or any other

I find this quite funny – how anyone could think that a disney ’star’ could pull off any role in New Moon is impossible to think about. Disney Channel can keep their actresses and actors for that matter!!

One word….WACK!!!!!

LOL.

i really hope they dont pout disney stars into this production, it would ruin the fan base all the HSM fans will be lining up to see newmoon! they should put in people who dont have a HUGE teen fan base such as family stars i dont care who it is as long as its not family

oh fuck no. no disney shit at all.

leah’s gotta be like bad ASS kick ass. i imagined her like dirty blonde and tom boyish. still thuper cool though..

NOT ASIAN OR GOD KNOWS WHAT HUDGENS IS. agh.

that would definitely ruin the movie. puhhlease.

and didn’t kristen say they didn’t want any like happy go lucky stars? like the edward cullen try outs?

NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOo!!! way

well i’d rather have New Moon NOT get publicity from Disney stars
it would be pretty funny though
a bunch of little kids going to see it cuz they’re High School Musical fans and they start screaming when they see Jasper all mean and scary in the first scene!

Taylor is flippin awesome!
sorry just had to add that
i mean c’mon hes trying to gain weight just to keep his part
and the other dude called New Moon “Twilight 2″ WTF???

I can not for the life of me stand either of those two. They are disney and New moon is no a disney movie. Neither of them can act to save their lives. They can find much much better people then this.
They just can’t put them in their honestly!

alright get outta here. wtf terrible choices for anything. disney to twilight. right.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
VANESSA WILL JUST KILL THE FRAKING MOVIE!!!!!
I MEAN BRANDA SONG IS OK
BUT VANESSA????
EWWWWWWWWWW
IM SORRY FOR PEOPLE WHO LIKE HER
BUT HSM WAS GOOD…. BUT HELL NO

hahaha reply to caro.. lol twilight 2 haha lmao that’s a good one ha! ha! HA!

VANESSA IS A SKANKKK!
i freaking HATE her and
it will be summits biggest
mastake to put that whore
in the movie. im mean she’s
already got my husband (zac efron)
wrapped around my finger
so she better not take twilight
from me to.

plus she’s just a HORRIBLE actress.

umm… are you serious? why would they even suggest these people? way to ruin the movie if they are picked for the role

HECK NO!! Disney already owns the rest of this God forsaken world!! why should they get a dabble in this twilight mess!! I could NEVER see vanessa hudgens in ANY role in new moon!! that’s partially b/c i think she’s just purely annoying and sounds like a demented baby doll when she laughs, which made all 3 HSMs horrible, but she’s just not fit for the role!! personally I have nothing against brenda song, but i don’t know how she would look as a native american..

Disney Stars??
**** NO!
I HATE Brenda. She is sooo ANNOYING!
&& Vanessa…
Shes a UGLY *****.
Neither of the should play Leah.
That would just bring disgrace to her name && who she is.
Leah is soo much better than those ugly bitches.
Sorry but they would ruin the movie && the others to come.
OH &&
Taylor IS going to be Jacob Black!
FO SHO!

ew. neither of them. they are both idiots and not even native american. they should find a girl that is the part is not just famous for saying crap like “yay me” or performing songs called “sneaker night” ew ew ew. emily and leah are way classy characters and these girls are not classy.

oh god no.
i really hope not.
they just both seem to perky…..too disney…. lol

EWWW. First of all i dont have anything against Brenda Song. But as leah?? No way!!
But as for Vanessa Hudgens, PUKE. Disney does not need anything to do with twilight. And, she would be a horrible vampire or werewolf. They should stick to some less known actors like they did with twilight. Or at least some better well known ones at least.

i wouldnt worry about the short part. easily, easily fixed. camera angles people.

but i think having a big face in a small role is not a wise idea.
esphally when both these are disney channel actors. i just cant see either of them in that role

i think amma be sick this is rediculous first off they put these ******* up on New Moon then **** that i can be in it to. All am saying is ill make sure that if i make it into the movie and one of these girly bitches are there amma throw up on them yes indeed espcially Vanessa Hudgens cant stand herrr ewww she need acting lessons eww
p.s she better stay off Robert IF she gets the part which after all these comments she probably wont muahahahahahahaha(evil)!

i think vanessa should be camen…
and i REALLY wanna know who the role of seth will be played by!!
i agree with alanna,she full on right!

Ewwwwwwwwwwwww!!!!!!!!!!!!!
There is a huge line of boundry between Disney crappy teenie crap and our beloved twilight….
Blah…. How could they even think this??!!!

Neither of them should be in the movie!!!! The only reason they want to be in the movie is cuz its huge and everybody who is anybody is going to watch in. If I had to pick it would be Brenda Song. She is way better than V!!!!!!

hahahaaahhahahaaaaaaa

those 2 in twilight? good joke!

i think VANESSA should play jane the evil volturi girl HAHAHAHA that would be funny and brendasong is okay for leah but i think som1 else should be leah

YOU GUYS DO KNOW THAT TAYLOR LAUTNER WAS A DISNEY STAR RIGHT BUT THEN AGAIN THAT WAS A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO AND HIS HOT NO WAY THEY CANT BE IN NM

HEY TWILIGHTY THATS WHAT I JUST TOLD YOU

SRRY TAYLORGIRL WORDS NOT MINE

Brenda Song would be cool!!! But I’m not so much for Vanessa Hudgens.

Oh PLEASE no Disney stars! No no no!!!

i would love it if vanessa was in new moon

but not as a vampire, she’s not pale enough,
but totally as like leah or emily
ome now i think of it more i think nessa would b AWESOME as emily!

btw just cuz they disney stars dont mean they cant do well in other movies

aw heeee-eeeee-eeeeellz no!

OMG!
The reason i dont watch HSM is because of Vanessa. She annoys me so much,
oh please dont let her make a fool of herself!
and as for brenda son; she’s asian guys?
COME ON!

WTF!Vanessa Hudgens?
Eca! :s neither of them!

NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO
NO WAY.
leah’s angry, sarcastic, and even b*tchy, remember?!
neither of them can pull that off.

HELLZ NO!!!!!!

uhm, it’s okay i guess..but if they could get someone else to play the role it would be better, but not for the role of Leah, don’t get me wrong, i like them both so much… i think Brenda could play leah because she is athletic and a black belt right? she could do a good leah…Vanessa on the other hand i would prefer her to play Emily than Leah, i think she would do a good Emily… Emily is the sweet type right? yeah, she could pull that off…

here’s my vote if Summit wants these two:
Vanessa Hudgens – Emily Young
Brenda Song – Leah Clearwater

*but if they could get another person who is stronger than Brenda, they should… Vanessa as Emily,,,,LOVE IT! CAN’T WAIT!

this could also test their acting skills, it honestly think that both can pull it off!!!

Brenda – Leah
Vanessa – Emily

“EWWWWWWW that is so gross if either of them are in the film it will suffer the rath of millions of teenage girls. I hate Vanessa and Brenda is good but not for this movie.”

Just pointing out that THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT YOU TWITARDS ARE.
And to those of you who aren’t actually teenage girls, you sure as hell act like them.
I’d like to see these actresses in this movie… It would make it even more laughable.

nooooo!
i am so sick of Disney stars. ugh.
twilight is too dark and serious for them and i have nothing against Asians or native Americans, but Brenda song is Asian not native American!!!!

ewwwww they both suck hugely :[[

No.No.No.No.No.No.No.No.NOOOOOO.!!!!
Thats is so gross both of them!!! I dont want to see any disney channel stars in New Moon!!! Thats is unbelievable that they would even think that!!!!! Vanessa a vamp? Um i Dont think so!!!!!! No. That would so kill our movie…. pick someone better plz!!!!!!!!!!!!

P.S I think Johnny Depp would make an awesome Aro???? Don’t you think????

Gosh now I’m angry they can not NOT be casted!!!

I ThinK this is so good because we can see they playing a difrent role and not always see they in suite life or high school musical!!
but honestly I Prefer vanessa.. (I love you vanessa I support you)

This would RUIN our Twilight! Either of these would just be tragic!!! They dont’ have the look for the part. Who wants a ‘giddy giggling’ vampire NOT US

HORRIBLE HORRIBLE IDEA! Disney is ICKKKY! Please do not taint our beloved character with fake tanner and bubble gum!

So that I can sleep tonight I am going to pretend that I didnt read this.

Personally I think both actresses are very lovely… But agree with what some of you are saying about leah needing to be strong stuborn and mature. I dont if i could really see either of these young ladies as the strong stuborn Leah. My personal Opinion is that they both look much to young and raw to play and heart torn Leah.
You knw why i Love Twilighters? Becasue you are all soo briliant and articulate about your statements some more harsh then others but you always put how you feel honestly I LOVE YA TWILIGHTERS!!!!

HEY TWILIGHTERS! i think that its a good chance for vanessa and brenda let disney for a moment!
i definally want to see they in a more serious roles! lol
I LOVE YOU EDWARD!=)

NO!NO!NO!NO!

THAT WILL TOTALLY KILL TWILIGHT FOR ME! THEY NEED TO LOOK FOR OTHER PEOPLE!
i don’t even know why it even crossed anyone’s mind to cast them! seriously people.

okay.. fine… it’s up to summit anyway… it’s okay for me atleast we could see if these girls are versitile actresses… vanessa a vamp? uhm… she could be JANE… yeah, I THINK VANESSA CAN PLAY JANE!

I think, NO!
Ew, hate them both (Especially Vanessa)! Get someone else please! And i dont think they can pull it off as Leah OR any of the vampires

I think they should stick to casting generally unknown people. Like, do more open calls for the new characters so that other already known actors and actresses don’t get any special treatment.

Ok so not trying to insult any disney fans out there but I don’t think Vanessa would be good for Leah or the other girl and I don’t even know who she is but I do think that they should consider Megan Fox for Leah I personally think she would be perfect for the role

WOW… ok… from what i hear it’s getting TOO out of hand!!! THIS ARE RUMORS!!! and i think RIDICULUS ones too!! do you really think that SUMMIT could even afford them?!?! or that they would let an already ’settled actor’ (to put it in words) stirr up their perfectly [twilight] cast of not so known actors (who by the way they have now shot to stardom!!) be mixed like that!??! BELIEVE ME!! it’s defficult to even bother beliving these RUMORS!!! and to clear things out too.. WHO SAID SUMMIT WAS MAKING THESE RUMORS!?!?!? yeah i’m not their biggest fan for the whole taylor thing… but please keep in mind that rumors esp. with BIG NEWS can be easilly meddled with!!! SO…TRUST ME PEOPLE!!!! THIS SOOO SEEMS LIKE A LONG SHOT!!!!!!!! for either of them.. (no offense to them they’re ok) BUT.. i’m confident that they will cast more unknowns to give them higher shots toward hollywood.. like they have now.. soo… CHILLAXX PEOPLE!!!!

Vannesa a vampire??? Wierdddd…. sooo not possible. And neither of them would make a good Leah. They should just find some other MAYBE talented nobodys, like Jinxx said.

there from DISNEY?????? there not twilight materiel there too dollfaced!

When I read the article my heart stopped in shock. Vanessa Hudgens would only ruin it for so many. It would be a real let down if she were cast for ANY role in the series. I just can’t see a fit anywhere for her. Have to agree I am going to pretend I didn’t read this.

NONE! no disney stars. they’re driving me crazy.
and Vanessa a vampire? that’s just not right…

EWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWK,,,,, PLEASE NO THEM NOT THEM, THEY REALLY DONT LOOK LIKE THE ONES IN THE BOOK !!!! NO PLEASE NO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IT WOULD MAKE THE MOVIE GO SO DOWN AND BE A REALLY CRAP MOVIE, IF YOU PUT TWO BAD ACTOR THERE , VANESSA ND THT OTHER GIRL ARE CRAP !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NOPPPPPPPPPE !!!!!! PLEASE NO !!!!!!!!!!1

Oh nonononoonoonnonononoononono. I can’t imagine anyone wanting either of them. DEFINITELY NOT VANESSA. NO DISNEY. PLEASE.
But I’m pretty sure we’ll be saved, because they are just rumours and both are so horrible choices XD

The problem is that Vanessa or that girl, arent even as famous as them! You knw,, course they will find other people, they neeed to find people tht look like the ones in the book , so i dont think it will matter much if they’re famous or not, they only have to be good at acting right? ,

Suuure…have a disney star as Leah
Heck..why not have the friggin Jonas Brothers as the volturi!

They`re screwing the movies up if they seriously consider getting either of those girls to play Leah >.>

Well for my personal opinion!!!
it should be :

MALESE JOW (show UnFabulos)

I really think she has the face stucture & attitude for the role!!..

but of course that is my opinion<3<3

-dee

When I read it, I was like “WHAT?! OMFG!” Both of them definitely CANNOT play ANY roles in New Moon. They look way too YOUNG and soft and IMMATURE to be in New Moon. Although Kristen Steward is only 18 (or 19 if next year), she looks really mature and strong.

And Vanessa as a vampire? I can’t imagine that for a second.

Summit Entertainment certainly gotta find someone older than them but not too old and look stronger. if I’m not mistaken, Leah is a black.

P.S.
Didn’t a lot of Twi-Hards say mean things like this about Rob<3…just wondering

When I read it, I was like “WHAT?! OMFG!” Both of them definitely CANNOT play ANY roles in New Moon. They look way too YOUNG and soft and IMMATURE to be in New Moon. Although Kristen Steward is only 18 (or 19 if next year), she looks really mature and strong.

And Vanessa as a vampire? I can’t imagine that for a second.

Summit Entertainment certainly gotta find someone older than them but not too old and look stronger, more ferocious. if I’m not mistaken, Leah is a black.

OMG! if any of them are casted in New Moon it will ruin the film. Vanessa….common, what the hell were they thinking even considering her! I really hope they respond to these post and get their head straight, but hopefully these are just rumours!

at the sydney twilight convention nikki reed announced that she wanted her friend to be leah but it wasnt anything final

I don’t hate them but I think neither of them would be a good choice for any Twilight character

-sighs.-
Are we even going to go there?
Why waste our breath?
Someone should’ve saw this coming considering the horrible decisions Summit and the casting crew have been making lately…

I read on here that someone wanted Camille Gauty and I didn’t know who that was soo i Googled her and I remember here from the Disney Channel movie Gotta Kick It Up and her character was a very sarcastic and somewhat snotty girl but she also had a semi-sweet side and thats how Leah is and I think Camille Gauty……

But out of these 2……I neither. They have played very funny and sweet characters and thats not how leah is at all and plus neither of them look like Leah is described sooo…..I mean dont get me wrong they’re both good actresses but not for the Twilight Saga…..
I choose neither!!

Vanessa is a good Leah but yes, too short. She is very pretty so a vampire would be good for her. I don`t think Brenda is a good Leah only because (not to be racist at all) but she is asian-at least I think-and so she is a bit unsuitable for a native american.

no.no.no.no.no.no.no no disney stars!
especially vanessa hudgens lets not add any more drama to the twilight actors; plus she sucks!
keep her on hsm away from twilight.

ewwww..i don’t want neither of the two!!!

esp..vanessa hudgens..don’t want to her on the movie!!!

do they have no choice???
this sucks!!!

Neither, pls!!! I’d rather they use lesser-known or new actors/actresses for Twilight Saga.

I have to agree. These two are way over used. They won’t be cast because so far, every single person that has been cast in Twilight has been virtually unknown. It won’t happen.

No they’re not good enough for leah, and gross vanessa can not be a vampire!

Why can they just stick to up and coming actors that arent the most popular…besisdes the cast already. Popular faces would ruin the essence that is Twilight. Neither of the options above even look Native American. They need to do better.

NO NO NOOOO NO!!!!!!!!!!
If I hear anything about a disney product infiltrating Twilight I will abandon it.

and i don’t want to have to do that

LOL,neither xD

No don’t pick either of them!!! Q’orianka Kilcher would make an awesome Leah…I looked her up after reading some of the posts and totally agree… she was exactly how I pictured Leah while reading! They need to pick someone who is actually (or at least somewhat looks like) Native American, hello! Neither of those 2 look like they could play Leah; and Vanessa as a vampire?? She’s not exactly how I pictured Jane….nooo!! Find someone else!

Why would they do that to us!!!!! I don’t like them at all!!!! WTF NO NO NO!!!!!

Due to the limited amount of maturity that is required if one wishes to even consider enjoying these books, I think both of these girls are too much role models for aspiring young women for the role. Disney Channel tries to inspire and teach propriety. Twilight and all associations are examples of – to be quite blunt – immaturity and harrassment. To associate Disney Channel stars with this kind of stockholm syndrome would be the most damaging sort of attention and connection they could make. Therefore, choose someone more often associated with these qualities, and leave the wholesome stars alone.

[...] the original post on Twilighters.org Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and [...]

I don’t think that any of them would really fit the Leah I see in my mind.

OMG! PLEASE DONT GET GIRLS FROM DISNEY & HSM! THE MOVIE ITSELF WOULD BE TERRIBLE GET SOMEONE ELSE THAT ISNT GIRLY!

okay. this is so stupid. vanessa hudgens needs to stick to musicals and exposing nudy pics to the web, and brenda song, who the hell is that? they are not women enought to play leah, there to sweet, and to just LAME!

OMC!!NO DISNEY STARS!!!!!
use all the nickelodeon stars just not disney stars!Vanessa would ruin the whole thing but maybe Brenda could pull it off if she got lessons but proabably not.

NONONONO!!!!!!

DO NOT. THAT WOULD SUCK. theres so mny better people for the roles why ruin the film with them. NOT NICKELODEON EITHER. KAY THANKS.

I was actually thinking Camilla Belle as Leah. She’d be good for it I think.

well…if i had to choose between the 2 for Leah…i would have to say Vanessa…just because Brenda looks way too little-kiddish and Vanessa looks more like someone u could see as a werewolf! but honestly i don’t think either of them would make the perfect Leah! i actually don’t know who would make a good Leah…its gonna behard to find someone to play her…

…and to Emilyyy….no Camilla Belle would NOT make a good Leah!!

oh yeah and as for Vanessa being a vampire….NO WAY!!!!!! she may be ok enough to be a werewolf but she is no vampire!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

WE WILL GET ALL OUR FRIENDS NOT TO GO SEE THIS MOVIE IF EITHER OF THEM HAVE ROLES IN IT!

I would hate to see either of them to be leah or a vampire!!!!!! leah is indian not asian!!!! =[ i really dont like vanessa anyway! lets not have a dinsney star that is really popular try to take over our beloved twilight saga!!!!!!! =[

if it has to be ether one of them, i would chose brenda.

NO! NO! NO!!!!!! THAT WOULD BE THE WORST MISTAKE TO MAKE!!!!!!! THEY ARE NOT CUT OUT TO BE LEAH OR EVEN IN THE MOVIE!!!!! IT WOULD JUST RUIN THE MOIVE!!!!! I DO NOT WANT TO SEE ANY OF THEM IN NEW MOON!!!! IT’S NOT RIGHT!!!!! I WOULD HATE TO SEE ANY OF THOSE DISNEY CHANNEL STARS AS LEAH!!!! NO WAY!!!!

Sorry…I’m gonna have to do this…
Ick ick ick ick ick ick ick ick! I know these are just rumors but still. (Shudder) I’m feeling a little sick just thinking about it. Neither of them would make a good werewolf period.

ok, other than the fact that i HATE the disney channel stars, I honestly think that they would NOT make a good Leah Clearwater… I don’t think ANY Disney Channel Stars should be because they don’t deserve having their name in anything twilight related they are too good for them, and as for the crap about Taylor Lautner, DON’T FIRE HIMM!!!!! I mean, in a few pictures that i’ve seen, taylor and the other guy are about the same height, some taylor looks even taller than him.. plus taylor does NOT have a baby face he’s 16 and major hot… but i prefer robert/edward.. though he looks A LOT better in the movie than outside, especially cause he got that new hair cut D:

Q’ORIANKA KILCHER for LEAH! People look her up! She would be perfect! I’ve seen her movies and she could be the PERFECT Leah! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! I hope they do Q’orianka for Leah, she is one of my favorite actresses! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Q’ORIANKA KILCHER! Who agrees with me?

Why disney channel stars? Uhh… I would prefer someone else >.> This rumor is probably just that: a rumor.

I think it would be really cool if Brenda got a part. I mean, she was an avid fan of the books before the movies.

Copy and paste this if you agree!
Q’ORIANKA KILCHER FOR LEAH!

ok vanessa as a vamp….. not gonna work i personally think. and i’m not reely sure bout having them play leah either. no offense to fans of these ppl but i think too much disney any disney person would NOT WORK!!! ~agree with julie~

EWWWWWW to both! What are they thinking?!?!?!?!?!? Oh my gosh, both of these would be tragically horrible.
TRY AGAIN SUMMIT or whoever made this aweful suggestion…

NEITHER TO BOTH !
But if I had to choose,
DEF. Vanessa Hudgens cause Brenda Song is just UUUUGH !

NO NO NO NOT A DISNEY KID!
i wonder if summit realizes that they don’t look anything like a Quileute…..
also: how about someone with actual acting skills?

EVERYTIME I LOOK AT THIS IT DRIVES ME INSANE !!
THAT DIRECTOR HAS GONE OVER THE EDGE !
HE CANNOT , I REPEAT CAAAAAAAAN NOT PUT THEM IN AS LEAH !!! THEY ARE WAY TO PERKY FOR THE PART OF LEAH, A BROKEN HEARTED CRUEL WEREWOLVE !!!

Hell NOOO!!! Leah Is a kick ass character! And one of my favorites! Disney stars would DESTROY her character!

NO! NO! NO! They will suffer greatly from putting on these disney stars!! NO MORE DISNEY STARS!!!!! NO MORE!!! tht just shows this amazing movie isnt out there for people whos hormones arnt raging and who actually like the movie instead of only thinking about how hot rob pattinson is but instead for all those tweens who only like the movie because “OMG EDWARDS SO HOTT.” make this movie enjoyable for those tht it is meant for and do not put disney stars in it.. PLEASE!!!! PLEASE FIND AN ACTUAL NATIVE AMERICAN!!! NOT DISNEY STARS!!!

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO DONT RUIN THIS MOVIE WITH THEM! (i’d rather choose brenda over vanessa no offense guys i can’t stand her!)

OMG NEVER EVER SHOULD EITHER OF THESE PLAY LEAH!! she is a H A R D – A S S, NOT A GOODY GOODY! they couldnt even resemble her in apperance hello!! SHES NATIVE AMERICAN…NOT AISIAN..OR PERKY BEAUTY QUEEN! AND NEITHER AS A VAMP!! if chris weitz picks one of these he has gone OFF HIS ROCKER AND I(AND MANY OTHERES)WILL BE PI^%ED

OH AND KEEP TAYLOR

Hell no Disney stars please the movie would be shit.

NOOOOOO!!!!!! I dont want to wach New Moon sitting next to some 4 year old just because their idol disney teen star is in the movie!!! I want to sit next to a REAL Twilighter who will understand when I cry when Edward leaves and cry with me even though I dont know them! Because just being Twilighters we have a special bond. A Twilight bond! And no 4 year old is goning to provide that kind of bond!!!!!!!!!!

Ummm i like……… NEITHER!!! I don’t like either of them. One is a slut who poses nude and the other(brenda) isn’t bad but isn’t leah.

old news. those RUMORS came out a month ago. and yes, they’re just RUMORS. i love how all you little girls are screaming and cussing and totally outraged. Quit bashing on them. So what if they’re Disney stars? RUMORS. I doubt either of them would be considered. But Vanessa looks more Native.

Please don’t choose either of them ! Who wants some disney stars in New Moon!? Neither of them would fit Leah in the movie. They seem to peppy, and Leah and New Moon are darker.. If that makes sense?:S:P

Ewww No Don’t Put Them!
I HATE Vanessa Hudgens.
She’s A Little Skank.
Brenda Song’s Like Whatever, But She
Doesn’t Seem Well Enough To Play Leah.
&& Also No Disney Stars.
Vanessa Doesn’t Act Good, && Brenda
Seems Only Good At Being A Rich Girl.
Please Pick Someone Else.
Besides They Work For Little Kids, Not Teenagers Or Adults.

Neither, they should cast unknowns or rarely-knowns

wtf
disney characters? really? leah is supposed to be strong, vanessa is all happy and ish. PLEASE NO! and brenda…eeh she gets no votes just because she signed a contract with disney lol but i think Rosario Dawson would be a great Leah. shes strong and plus we already kno she can play an emotional person

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
i do not want vanessa to be a vampire shes a slut noooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
i’d rather the other chick even though i’ve never heard about her…

I will refuse to watch New Moon if either of them-or any other Disney actor-is cast as Leah.
Nothing against Brenda Song, but I just can’t see her being a good Leah.
And Vanessa? UGH.

NO NO NO

I LOVE TWILIGHT

PUTTING BRENDA OR VENESSA IN WILL JUST BE SHIT

IT WILL ROWEN IT

NO NO NO DISNEY STARS

THEY WONT FIT I WILL BE PISSED OFF IF THEY DO CAST EATHER OF THEN FOR LEAH

NNOOOOO i cannot belive there even considering thease 2 for the part! im already madd enough that they might be getting rid of laylor lautner! omg! if they wanted some one taller they shuld have tought about that before the world excepted him as out jacob black in my oppinion there could be no better jacob and if they make ither one of those disney princesses leah im not seeing the movie!

also just to add i soooo agree with j9 when they said rosario dawson would make a awsome leah!

ok so brenda song COULD NOT be leah. i know she’s capable of not being perky but seriously that would be a joke if she was. no one would take her seriously. and vanessa could pass for the lovelorn leah and make the pack suffer from her unrequitted love for sam uley.. but i highly doubt she can play the fierce leah in the other books. i mean come on vanessa hudgens going after newborns… yeah no. but i could see her as a vamp. but more so the one that gets killed for saying information to the volturi before she was sure of an immortal child. now THAT would be worth watching. and she would only be seen in one movie. the last one. where they hardly concentrate on her until they kill her. now seriously i would love to see that one happen ^_^

HELL NO!!!! NO FREAKIN DISNEY STARS ALLOWED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! is this some kinda joke? they better not be in it. at all.

Oh lordy. I don’t mind Brenda so much , not as a werewolf though , but vanessa ?! i can’t stand her and i don’t think most teenagers can! They can do sooooo much better with Leah! Stay away from disney! And vanessa should not even be in the same category as vampires. She no where near pretty enough. She’s too….disney .

VANESSAA!!!

seriously? wow none of them should be Leah. Isn’t Leah supposed to look beautiful and exotic? no offense but i dont think a disney star is good enuf

THE TWILIGHT FRANCHISE SUCKS IF THIS HAPPENS!!!!

Seriously, what the fucking HELL?! Brenda is like Korean so that’s in Asia and Vanessa is part FILIPINO so that’s in Asia too–SINCE WHEN IN THE WORLD IS A NATIVE AMERICAN ASIAN?! I AM SORRY; I AM ASIAN, BUT THIS CROSSES THE DAMN TREATY LINE!!!

*makes gagging noises*
IF THIS HAPPENS, IM SO DONE WITH TWILIGHT!!!! NO FUCKING DISNEY STARS WHO CANT SING OR ACT ALLOWED!!!!

VANESSA!!!

OMG! I NEVER SAW THAT COMING!!!!!

Alright, don’t mind that the 2 girls under scrutiny are Disney, but they do not fit the character for Leah or Jane as some had said. I think Q’orianka Kilcher (from New World) for Leah and actually Kristin Chenoweth (from Pushing Daisies, with dark hair) for Jane. She’s 4 feet 11″ and very child like, even her voice. Those are my fantasy choices

OMG. you people say you “DONT WANT DISNEY STARS” but then again you ALL WANT TAYLOR LAUTNER??? He was in ‘Shark Boy and Lava Girl’…if i remember correctly that IS a disney movie, right? AND Kristen Stewart was in Zathura…which has been featured on Cartoon Network( and/or Disney Channel). There is nothing wrong with disney stars!!!

OOOHH…what vampire would vanessa play, though? None of them fit her…..?? I LOVE DISNEY CHARACTERS. Taylor was a disney character once too.

i think both girls would be a bad move because:
Brenda Song is Thai-American. Leah Clearwater is a Quileute Indian. Then there is Vanessa Hudgens. EWWW. I really think that is a bad move because she is trashy and personally what I’ve heard makes me not like her in the least bit. I would be very disappointed if she was casted as Leah. If I was given the choice, I would cast Genevieve Cortese. But out of the two given choices I would choose Brenda Song.

I think Q’orianka Kilcher would be a perfect Leah, she did amazing in The New World as Pocahontas. What do you guys think?

Ehn. I’m not taking either of these rumors to heart. High profile stars, like Vanessa, constantly have casting rumors swirling around them. Vanessa has been rumored to be in a version of ‘The Dreary and the Naughty’ and ‘Dungeons and Dragons’ this past year and neither have been true. Besides, remember all those Batman casting rumors? Or that Zac Efron was going to be in POTC 4?

I’ll wait till we get the green light on the casting before making a judgment.

If any of the two r leah i am gonna b so upset that might just make the movie not that good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Leah is suposed to be kinda girly and kinda tombboshy like a mix of the two and really pretty and totally BADASS!!!!!!!!!!!!I’m sorry but those 2 could never act like leah!!!AT ALLLLL.

OMFG HELLLLLLLLLLL NO!!!!!!!!!!! Vanessa Hugens is SUCH a WHORE!!!!!!! Shes to short and too tan not to mention shes UGALY!!!!!Bendas okay but shes asain no offense and if she was Leah she would have to be tan!Plus she doesnt have the face for Leah.Leah is suposed to be tall beautiful but at the same time shes tuff and AWSOME!!!!! NO DISNEY STARS!!!!!!!!!!!

BTW I think Megan Fox or the girl form the Unborn could be Hedi…just a thought.

i think jessice szohr is better than vanessa hudgens. aha!

i think either one of them would ruin the whole movie. no offence to either, but they have their own movies and shows. let some newcomers try out.

um. WTF?!
that girl on the left, she’s not just a bad actress, SHE IS HORRIBLE. i would actually cry if any of those … wannabes will take role in twilight

NOOOOO!!!!!!!!!! They’re terrible!!!

Hell to the no! Neither of them! honestly having vanessa in it would ruin it…. all i would be able to think about is “wow this girl is from high school musical…. why and the hell is she in the movie?” and brenda…. not so much…. both of them are to short…. if they ended up in the movie it would not only ruin the movies in general but i honestly don’t know if i would enjoy watching or even want to see it. I say keep searching for much better actresses… maybe some newcomers.

i think these to actresses are better fitted for the Disney channel type roles, or at least right now in they’re careers. I just REALLY can’t see either one of them playing anyone from the books in the movies, and I doubt any characters would need to be created.

No offense to the actresses or their fans, but Disney stars should stick to Disney. That’s all I’m going to say on that.

Q’orianka Kilcher seems like she would suit Leah well. At least she’s half Native American.

Vanessa?Brenda?ooh god NO NO NO NO NO!!seriously no disney kids no nickelodeon kids and of course no Camilla Belle!comm on this will suck=/
and taylor?he is just p-e-r-f-e-c-t he is a must have IN TWILIGHT=)

Omg Honestly wat r da chances dat either of theese would ever get a part in New Moon!!
Dis is jus a rumer! Vanessa couldnt act to save her live and Brendas better with short tv scripts lik site lif!
i hav nuthin against disney but none of dem could handle an actual part in a actual movie espially New Moon!!! But as i said ders no chance it could be true i no summit almost made a huge mistake wen it came 2 jacob but i’m sure de hav enough sense 2 keep disney far awawen it comes to twilight!!

Neither! They are both bad (disney!) actors. Having either of them in the movie would ruin it.

I agree wit Taylor

Shouldn’t Leah be significantly shorter than Jacob? So, I don’t really understand the argument against Vanessa, although I just picture her as a HS Musical girl and not Leah. Does anyone know if the rumors about this girl being Leah are true???
http://nicole-lee-smith-photos.blogspot.com/

they are not allowed to contaminate Twilight. i know casting is now different because they have way more money + box office success, but the casting team should look for actual actresses.

I think Brenda song would be a great leah!!! that’s exactly how I pictured her!

Okay no. A really good Leah would be Camille Guaty. Look her up and tell me she’s not perfect?

IF VANESSA IS CHOSEN I WILL DIE

While I agree that neither of them should get the role I think that Vanessa is good enough and has the right background (Spanish, Chinese, Filipino, Spanish, Native American) to get the part. But no one seems to look that much further than Disney. And Vanessa is really a musical star. If she did a bad job of it all the younger kids that watched it would be so upset (I should know)

OME!!!! im just fine with brenda song being leah but… WHY THE CRAP WOULD YOU WANT VANNESA THE FREAKIN SLUT TO BE EVEN ON THIS MOVIE!!!!!!!!

I would boycott the movie if Vanessa hudgens was in it. She’s a skank and from disney, kinda ironic. NOOOOOOOO TO VANESSA

Neither
But between them I pick Vanessa

OMG neither need to b involve with twilight series.

Hell no! No disney b****es in new moon; I refuse to go to the movie if either of them gets the part of Leah. That’s crap.

hate both of them im tryin out for leah so hope i make it i promise ill be good love yaw

eww neither!!
i would rather see meagan fox play leah!

Yeah im with (Savannah) MEAGAN FOX
would be a better leah!!!

MEAGAN FOX !!!!!!!!!!! WOULD TOTALLY BE A BETTER LEAH THEN THE SKANK VANESSA AND BRENDA IS BETTER DOING TV SHOWS SERIOUSLY PPL !!