what?! NOOO! DAKOTA = JANE! NOOOO!

first comment

aw boo. i thought i had first comment. well, she’s pretty but Dakotas def got the creepy kid thing goin on. good luck to lucy tho!

Personally, I think she fits a more Leah role than a Jane, but that may be just me!

i totally agree…The only Jane is Dakota!!!

Hm. I’m not sure about her being Jane. But I could definitly see her being a vampire. A Denali sister, perhaps? *shrug* I can’t remember if they’re really in New Moon, though. >.>

I see her as more of a Leah….

Yes, I think she would be a better Leah, but *shrugs* who knows.

I think her or dakota would look the part.
But i don’t know anything about lucy’s acting…
all i know is that dakota is absolutely amazinggggg.
so…idk! haha
until i see lucy’s acting… dakota.

ugh, i feel bad saying this but i have disliked her ever since she got into acting. Dakota is the only Jane in my eyes.

i think she’d definetly be a good leah or denali sister..definetly better than vanessa hudgens. But dakota should still play jane:)

jane not soo much but for other characters yes!!

I think she may be a little too old for Jane’s character, but i think she definitely has a more cute and innocent look about her. It would be cool if she got offered another role in Twilight series though!

so i think that dakota would be a better jane but lucy would be a good jane. i think she would be alot better than vanessa hudgens because i can picture lucy doing a more serious roll and acting stuck up for the part but i cant picture that for vanessa. and also i just like lucy more!!

dakota will rock as jane and i am happy she got the role . i think maybe lucy should be leah or one of denali sisters

i think dakota will be a better jane. but i do think that lucy would be a better leah than vaness haudgens because i can picture lucy playing a more serious roll and acting stuck up like leah for the roll but i just cant picture that with vanessa. and i just like lucy better

I think that she would be a good leah and they should keep Dakota as Jane!

How old is she? She looks awesome!

But I was already counting on Dakota being Jane (I think its a great idea)
But I think she should be in New Moon, IDk who…Maybe Leah? Or someone else, Heidi? hmm…

more of a leah!!!but i still dont want
dakota fanning as jane~!!1

i think she would be a good leah.
I watch Privileged and she would definatly be good for leah!

TEAM DAKOTA!!!!!!

;she looks more like a leah cuz she doesnt have sweet face and she isnt that white (sorry if i offend any of u guys but u kno wat i mean)and she has black hair or a denali sistwr but who knows!!!!:)

dakota will be a perfect jane cuz they described her as child like

I dont think she would be a good Jane. She should definately be a Denali sister though.

she NEEDS to be emily. NEEDS. O_O

i see her more of a Denali sister or Leah who knows though. Dakota is the only Jane though.

I think she looks more like a Denali sister. Shes very pretty, Dakota is Jane, i think she will do a good job.

i think that dakota would be way better for Jane. i can see her as a Denali sister too

shes way to old man she would be good for leah maybe but dude jane wat ?

This girl is so beautiful! The moment I saw her on her show Privledged I adored her. I think she would be more perfectly suited for Leah as well. I would be thrilled with that news. However, I still also hope they consider Q’orianka Kilcher.

isn’t Jane like 12???? Lucy fits the description…but 12???

Yeah, I agree with like almost everyone, she would be better for Leah.

god she’s GORGEOUS. she needs to be Emily.

I don’t know if she would make a good Jane. I think she should be Emily. But I also don’t like the idea of Dakota being Jane either. I thought Jane was supposed to be short and child like. Also I thought Jane had dark hair.

She is awesome. I’m sorry, I just can’t see Dakota as Jane. They should stick to not so name actors for these movies. Lucy was really good when she played that goth girl on Wizards of Waverly Place. And an amazing Rose on Privileged. She could pull of Jane with the right make up. I really hope they don’t chose Dakota.

I don’t know about her has jane..like everyone has been saying..she looks more like Leah….
BUT… I’ve been wondering…if they plan on making Breaking Dawn..I dk if they have decided yet…I hope so… have they mentioned this to the new additions. i’d hate for them to sign dakota for new moon and then have her decide not to want to be in BD. and then they change actors… that would suck.

I am thinking that she would make a great Leah!!!!

aw no – she looks like she would have been good for the part. she sounds nice too… enthusiastic even though they didn’t pick her

dakota, i agree, is too well known really. there’s a possibility she might monopolise the film. (plus, i have a little suspicion that she’s publicising her AND SUMMIT ENTERTAINMENT’S new film)

twilightkid12

Could i please apply for Emmett?? If renesmee is taken?? thanks

PS i promise i will change name soon

haha her last name is hale:-)
shed be a good leah or emily, just not jane
cant wait for new moon!

I still don’t lyk Dakota Fanning, but Lucy doesn’t really look lyk a Jane to me. I could see her as one of Tanya’s clan, or one of the nomads, in Breaking Dawn, or as Leah, sure. but not Jane – soz man :S

i think she would make a great Jane,
but I like Dakota as Jane too.
but omigosh, she would make one SICK vamp! she should try out for definetly a denali sister, like Kate, or if they do a breaking dawn movie (which they better!) she could be one of the vamps in the end, like maggie, or charlotte!

i really like Dakota Fanning more.

She should be one of the Denali sisters.

I like Dakota Fanning more

SHE SHOULD B LEAH !

but as jane,, sorry IT HAS 2 BE DAKOTA FANNING !

shes rly pretty nd she def should be a vampire in new moon

I agree she would be a good Leah, or even a Emily! I like the idea of Emily more, since Lucy is shorter and Emily is too.. Not so much a Denali sister though, they need a more defined elagance where Lucy is pretty but she would need to be taller in my opinion.

Everyone should give Miss Dakota a break. She wont take over New Moon. Shes not sucking uo to SUMMIT because she is in their new movie Push. Shes an AMAZING actress and everybody knows it. Shes fits the part of Jane. And even Peter Facinelli wants her for Jane! I AGREE WITH PETER!

would still love to be jacob or seth

i agree that dakota should b jane she def has the creppy child look down. thats a complaiment not an insult:)

hey carlisle!

Yeah I definitely think Dakota should be Jane..she totally fits the character! I would love to see Lucy as Leah or Emily or later on, one of the Denali sisters maybe; she totally looks like she belongs in the movie somewhere!

Dakota Fanning? Isn’t she a little young? Oh well, I still love her!

how is lucy a leah or emily? nahhh.. def doesn’t fit those 2 characters. she would make a good jane though. like, she’s got the hair, and the innocent look but still look all grr. she’s great!

Ugh I think both arent that good Im not a fan of Dakota and I dont want Lucy though but she could not be Leah at all maybe she sorta looks like her but i dont think she could pull of that bitchy additude Leah has but I’d rather have her than Vanessa Porno

i dont really see her for that part..to grown up loooking for it.
but i like the idea as i hope there going for; Using non- known actors.
it just makes it better.
i seen on this other website this girl might play emily, her name was america something, {not the girl from ugly betty} – she looked perfect for it.

thats hilarious that she is david henrie’s gf…she was on his show. lol

Guess what Lucy? You’re not going to get the part. Sorry. Jane=Dakota Fanning end of story.

lucy hale would be better than vanessa hudgens as leah.

i think both dakota and her are good. i think she would be a pretty good leah. For whoever does play leah, do u think they’ll make her cut her hair, or put a wig on?

Sorry but i don’t think she is the type to play a vampire. I would want to still see dakota as jane

hmm. i must agree that dakota has the creepy kid think. you know? ever seen hide and seek? very crazy!

i kind of think Dakota is just a little young for Jane’s part.maybe in another year or two she might fit it………i don’ know

aww she would make a good jane

Dakota: June Lucy: Leah
But make sure that both actresses r able to be in all of the movies (should they be made) change of charter would be a real disappointment to most fun’s just look at what happened with Taylor:Jacob so be sure

Hey as Nicole said in one of the comments that Q’orianka Kilcher would be good 4 the role of Leah I think that she would be better as Emily if she’s not 2 talk

i think they should keep dakota as jane. Cuz yeah, she got the creepy kid look.

But i think lucy wud be good as emily or leah tho. I don’t know why, but she’s a werewolf type…

i think they shud keep dakota as jane. And yeah, she got the creepy kid look. No offense.

But i think lucy wud be a good emily or leah tho. I dnt kmow why, but she got the werewolf type…:p

i think she should be cast as Leah and Dakota as Jane!!

I think that she would be so much better, cause Jane is described has an extremly dark skinned person, so lets face it, Dokota Fanning is just way to pail. But the person above me ios wrong, i think that the person who plays leah, must be from a native american tribe.

i like dakota fanning more xD
she should be cast as emily or a denali vamp…
i don’t kno

she is totally pretty she should be Leah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

SHE IS PRETTY BUT I LIKE DAKOTA AS JANE + DAKOTA IS WHITE – LUCY WOULD MAKE A BETTER LEAH AND LUCY in previledge is stuck up and mean like LEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Dakota Fanning is going to be a terrible Jane. I’m actually really mad about it.

im trying out for maggie in breaking dawn!!!

my name in real life is maggie, too! Hoorah!

dakota fanning is creepy she went from cute little girl (charlottes web) to creepy little goth (hound dog, push)
i really think lucy hale has more of the jane look than dakota, anyway

OMG!! you people are nuts Dakotas a good actor BUT JANE HAS DARK HAIR!!!(Lucy Hale!!!:)

You kno leave Dakota at Jane I’m not a big fan of Dakota but I have other plans for Lucy…….she should be Leah I mean if you’ve seen her on Wizard’s of Waverly Place (& don’t give me that bs n say u havent cuz sum of u have so shut up) she wuz a gothic gurl n she held her feelings about justin inside so maybe she could play a mysterious Leah I mean when i read New Moon i thot leah wuz gona b dark haired not a BLONDE!!!!!