Real; she has to be played by someone! I think it would kind of ruin Reneesme if she was fake, CGI created
I’m sorry, but I really cant watch their videos. The women on there are always so fucking annoying.
Anyway, from what I get from the title, a CGI Renesmee would work, yes, BUT it’s not hard to find a few different actresses in different age groups to be Renesmee. I’ve read somewhere that it’d be hard to do, but it really isn’t. You see babies on TV shows all the time and they obviously cooperate for takes enough when possible, lol.
i personally think that Nessie should be real; she does have normal human traits, and if they need to CGI anything, that would probably have to be her birth and than her other vampire traits. but other than that, the only issue they could run into is probably finding young actresses that look like her. they could maybe CGI her as a small baby, because she doesnt talk, and than add in her actress for when shes old enough to talk and interact farther than what CGI had made her do when she was a day or two old; like laughing.
just my ideas, i hope they won’t CGI all of her, it will take away her charm, (:
I honestly could really care less about how they put in reneseme as long as they put her in!!!!! Though if I could choose I would say use an actress as much as possible then the things that you can’t have a 2 year old actress do use cgi.
I think they should make it into two movies. I just dont want them to end so soon. So if there is two they wont. I also think renesmee should be real. !00% Real. What are they thinking on trying to make it fake. There millions of fans who will be sooo upset if she is fake. I think that they should fingd the cutest baby and toddler and that should be her. If they do make her fake, I will be upset. It is just not rite!!!
i think renesemee should be 100% real of course. It’s the characters that make the movie. So “yes”, of course, real.
they should have a real person, otherwise she’ll be too weird
really hope it is not Chris Wietz…
REAL! Renesmee has to be REAL! It would just be stupid if she was CG!!!
i think Renesemee should be real and she should also be CGIed in so case , like her birth . and her vampire traits . & i also think that the movie should be made into one long movie . It will be worth it being one long movie , cause if it’s juss two movies , i would be going CRAZY ! It’s telling the story from two points of views , Bella’s , & Jacobs . So they should juss ahve like , a white screen or black it out when bella’s first story ends and then say jacobs, kinda like new moon .
You can’t have Renesmee as a real child because although she has the physical size of a toddler she has characteristics of and adult also so she is alot more intelligent than any child you could get to play her also she changes to much over such a short time that more than one actor would have to play her!
i think they should use a real character. the only problem is that she grows very fast so i think they would need more then one actress!! but if they have CGI i dont think it will be as good it wouldnt be the same.
I don’t think there is an ideal solution to portraying Renesmee on screen. I can understand wanting her to look authentic and using a real baby, but her character is simply too aware and has accelerated characteristics and something would be lacking without the use of CGI. Maybe a combination of both? oh and 2 movies for sure!
She totally needs to be a real person a cg vampire child might just look to fake.
She has to Be REAL!! it would jut stuff up the movie
maybe they could do a bit of both, real and CGI??
I saw this little girl on Grey’s. Her name is Mary-Charles Jones she was so cute. amazing for her age.
renesmee has to be real. if she was fake then that would just be stupid.. she is a key part of the movie so i think a special little girl should be able to play such a popular part!
CGI i think
In my opinion, just let the crew members do their job and we’ll see how the outcome is. If you don’t like it, too bad. Some of you want Renesmee to be 100% real but how is that possible? They need at least 3 actresses that look alike to play Renesmee and how often can you find 3 people that looks identical AND can act? You think it’s easy? Think again.
My opinion is that they should use real actresses for Nessie. And this thing about it being next to impossible to find at least three that look alike? So not true. And besides, isn’t this the part where the make up artists come in? And besides, the more tough parts that Nessie does can be solved with spcial effects, so I’m thinking that this can be solved with a little bit of both.
wat a stupid idea
I don’t know if this is where I am suppose to be leaving this comment, but, id like to say that I’ve been hearing that you guys are thinking about splitting Breaking Dawn into two movies and honestly I see why you guys would do that. I would assume because Breaking Dawn would be a very long movie, simply because it is the best book of the Twilight Saga because of everything that happens which is alot. But if you break it into two movies, everybody would see one part then who knows how long till the next part..it would just ruin everything. Make it into one big movie. I know a great deal of people who wouldn’t mind watching a 5 hour movie on Twilight. Please take into consideration. P.s please please don’t miss anything in the movie on Breaking Dawn im looking forward to almost everything that was in the book!
Why not have one child as Nessie? It doesn’t say anywhere that the scenes have to be filmed in a chronological order. One of the first scenes during principal photography they shoot would be Renesmee’s birth, and from that point on they stretch out her scenes over a long period.
Viewers won’t notice Pattinson or Kristen aging, but they will notice Nessie aging. Of course, it would also require a bit more than 3 months of shooting (I think that’s how much it took for Eclipse), but hey, it’s a long movie, or two! Which is the key, since a span of two movie releases would be enough for a toddler to grow enough.
I think John Doe has the right idea. By the time they finish filming both parts, your baby is not a baby anymore. You just have to shoot the early scenes first then the later scenes last. They do it in the movies all the time. It could work.
i think Nessie have to be real!!!
if it would be CGI she wouldn’t be the same cute renesmee of the books!!!!!
I would say that since this is a fictional/fantasy Nessie could be either way, so long as it done in good taste. in LOTR, the CGI looked real as any fictional character could look. I think Summit will do their best to not disappoint us.
Nessie can’t be CGI!!! NOOOOOOOOO!!!!
She has to be real it wouldn’t look right if she were CGI
Must be a human but of course not only one, according to story she grows up really fast, I think they can have different actresses, maybe sisters… then add CGI
I think that they should make Renesmee in CGI, but they should take the model of a child first. =)
I think that they should find an actress that looks older and then make a CG for when she was younger. Since here is very few things Renesmee does the first week or so there really is no point hiring two actresses. CG the first week of her life then bring in the actress.
And I don’t really want Chris back to direct the last one. Having different directors capture there ideas in each movie is really good. Even though I don’t think they chose the right director for the first one. But dosn’t matter now, that’s in the past.
Yes Nessie needs to be a real person! And my hope is that is is TWO very long movies. Afterall it is the last ~ make BREAKING DAWN
AFTER ALL MAKE BREAKING DAWN OVER-THE-TOP AWESOME!!!
Of course Renesmee has to be real!!!!!!!! What are they thinking?!?!?! She would look too fake in CGI if they don’t do it right, and that will happan if they have a poor budget. Plus, if Renesmee is done in CGI, all of her charm will be gone. SHE NEEDS TO BE REAL!!!!!!!!!!!!
i think nessie should be real.i think 2 movies would be ok,if thats what it takes to get everything from the book into the movie
nessie obviously needs to be real if she wasnt it would be to weird and two movies it will proubly be painful to have to wait for the second one but worth it when we get to see everything from the book
The clip wouldn’t play… but i think she should be real!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
it may seem like it will be easy but when she is born she acts like a one year old…i mean she is a week old and can TALK….a real human baby cant do that so it is definetly going to be tought for the director to choose what to do and make it work
If they do renesme as CGI I won”t even bother watching BD, she doesn”t have to be real the things about her were implied-thus they can do so in the movie you don”t have to show every little thing, as we found out from the bomb of newmoon. just hate the way the rest of the series is so f– d up!!!!
also it should be two movies….they will probably not let a movie be 5-6 hours long…but it would be AMAZING if they did
I also think they should have Renesmee (me) be a real little girl. and just use the same girl for the entire movie. And it would so be awesome if Breaking Dawn was like 6 hours long. but they would have to give us a bathroom break between the books like they’re when the first book told by Bella is over we get a bathroom break and then Jacobs book, bathroom break! I know it sounds weird but that way u wont have to miss anything because u have to pee. hehe
She could be real they could just add special fx to make her vampire like. I think if Renesmee is completely CGI, she will look totally fake. If Renesmee is bad quality I font think the movie would be as much of a success as it could be.
I hope they stay true to the book, and put everything in the movie. I would sit through a four hour movie if that’s how long it was. I wouldn’t care. Breaking Dawn is my favorite book. As far as Renesme, they should keep her real, that CGI crap makes it look fake. I also they put all the gore in the movie too. They’re worried about the kids that watch these movies. Kids these days are so desensitized I really don’t think it’s going to affect them.
She has to be real of course! if she’s CGI that’s going to ruin in because it would look all fake. They should just get a real person. An Breaking Dawn should definately be split into 2 movies
couldnt the o both, for different seens there are very smart great little actresses out there , im sure they could make what ever work with out it lookin to fake, thats movie magic right ? my 5 month old could play a bigging renesmee part lol
I think there is a point where Renesmee can be played by a young actress, but for a while I can’t find a way she could possibly be played by an actual child. Granted the time Renesmee will spend as an infant is minimal she will be FAR to aware. An infant can’t focus on a person the way Renesmee will need to. Once she hits the “toddler” stage I think it can be a combo. As someone else said have the parts that a real toddler can’t possibly do be CGI (obviously) but as much as it is possible have her played by a toddler.
As far as the movies themselves. I’m all about splitting them into two movies, I just don’t see how they can be even remotely “faithful” to the book and squeeze it into one movie.
They should pull a Ben Button and mix it up. All CGI will be too noticeable and all real won’t translate well. Both will be needed.
i think nessie needs to be an actress in order for the movie to seem right. and then the stuff that cant be done for reals can be cgi.
I think that Nessie should be real. But if they need to add some special stuff to the actor to better go by the book, then so be it!
On the idea of using only CGI, I think that it’s not the best idea but that it can be done. And if they do go through with that idea, it better be some darn good CGI! I’m talking Avatar or Transformers. Or better!
Either way, I’m suuupppeerr excited for BD to hit theaters, just as long as Chris doesn’t direct it. In my opinion, he sorta ruined NM…
I think she should be mostly real. But come on, they’ll need like 10 babies/little kids that all look completly alike at least because of her rapid growth. and all of these kids need to look like kristen/rob so it’s realistic. that is gonna be hard. but she can’t be totally fake or it would ruin her charm. And it should deff be one movie. i mean, where could they break it to make it 2? and when it comes out in theatures, who wants to leave halfway through the movie? and hoe long will the break be between the 2 movies? it can be one long movie and do reallly well. Ever heard of Avatar? it’s 3 hours long and doing REALLYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY well. And Twilighters are even more pumped. So Breaking Dawn could do better than Avatar.
I think that they might want to make her half and half. They could get an actress for some parts and they could do CGI for the other parts, or they could have an actress the whole time and give her CGI components, like her baby parts and her vampire abillities. And they should definitely make it one really long movie, I know a lot of people who would like that.
Suprisingly, if you add a pinch of asian and shorter hair my little sister, Abby(1 and a half years old), looks a whole lot like Renesmee. My opinion. =-) I also imagined Renesmee like my sis while reading the book!
OME OME OME OME OME OME OME OME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I LOVE RENESMEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! MAKE HER BE REAL AND PICK ME AS THE ACTOR TO PLAY HER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
She has to be real or it will ruin it, and wouldn’t it be kind a awkward to act like theres something there when its not. Renesmee can’t be a transformer!!
I really hope they use a real person, I think it could ruin the movie if they dont, it would just look really cheesey. Its such a amazing book I just hope they dont ruin it when they do the movie, they should make it into 2 movies just so they dont have to cut so much out like they did in New Moon.
I think that they should use both. A real child and then add in special effects where needed! Also, please make BD into two movies, its my favorite book and i really hope they put everything in the movie. Its the last book of course and it just makes everything fall into place. It would really suck if they left parts out like they did in new moon.
Renesmee should definately be played by a real actress with CGI special effects added. We don’t want her to turn out with a “Gollum-like” appearance that worked in Lord of the Rings, but would not work in Breaking Dawn.
She should be real! but they would need many many many Actresses because she grows very fast. but the thing is they would need an extremely smart child to do so. at the end(ish) of the book they say shes smarter than most adults, so maybe CGI would be needed in a few things. i think they should put Breaking Dawn into two movies, but if it was only one i would enjoy every hour of it =] if it was just one it would b at least 4 hours or more! im 13 and was extremely hyper at New Moon so it was hard to sit through 2 or 3 hours and appreciate it but i could handle Breaking Dawn because i love it toooooo much to not be able to sit still and pay attention
i think Renesmee should be REAL, point blank!! making her CGI would just make her look waay too fake. they could maybe use both but have an actress or a few. people saying that it would be hard to get a few babies to play her are wrong because i watch soap operas and they make their children grow up waay quicker than the adults and they don`t seem to have a problem with it. some people are saying that it would be hard to get an mature child which is also wrong because don`t you guys remember how Dakota Fanning was when she was younger?? she was very mature for her age. so i believe that Renesmee can be done REAL!!
the Breaking Dawn movie being split into two movies is stupid. i understand what people are saying about how they want it to be true to the book but i believe that they can make it true to the book if the movie is three hours long or even four. they know damn well that their fans will sit there for four hours. i know i would, plus Lord of the Rings done it so why can`t they?!
I really agree with you. I don’ get why people want 2 movies that means when the movie starts to get really good you have to leave and wait for part 2. And who knows when that will come out. Oh yea Renesmee sooo real.
She has to be real! Yes she goes through several transformations but I think that's possible with makeup or several different people as the role. She's not some wolf who needs CGI. She's still a person.
The main thing I didn't like about New Moon (other than the fact that Edward (Rob) got as much screen time as Jacob (Taylor) even though it should have been Jacob's movie) is that is was over too soon. Two hours and ten minutes is a good length for a movie, but too short for this story, so I certainly hope that Breaking Dawn is made into two Movies – maybe that way Jacob (Taylor) will get his screen time. Oh and I agree that Renesmee should not be CGI, that will ruin it for me.
I think she should be real, I have nothing to back it up though
ONE movie! REAL Renesmee! Nuff said!
This is what I think of this. Renesmee should be real but for some parts like her rapid grow rate they should use a LITTLE bit not a lot. It should be one movie. Why would you want to go see it then have to leave cause its two movies and right when it starts to get really good?
i think that it should be both… i mean i know alot of people will be so mad if shes all cgi but i mean people didnt get mad when they cgid edward sparkling in new moon (if you did then wow but im talking about the people in my area) so all the vampire traits need to be cgi… including the birth, but half way: vamp. traits, and her growing new each day and birth cgi but the other parts diffrent actress because i would be fine if she was all cgi but i think it would be best halfway because it will seem more real and i think it would b hard for the actors to be talking to space including jake:/ but thats what i think
I think she should be real it would suck if she wasn't don't use the cgi unless you have to
She should be real with a lot of special effects. Special effects now days can slim someone, make them taller, change their voice completely, and pretty much do what needs to be done for Renesmee's character. Even though CGI looks very very real, it just wouldnt look right having a baby as a CGI. Just my opinion, though.
Renesme should be half and half,
the guy who directed Eclipse should direct BD,
and it should be 2 movies so nothing to important gets cut.
i'm done now.
i think renesmee has to be 100% cgi because there are girls that are going to be jealus of the person that is doing renesmee so i say that renesmee has tooo be cgi
fan number 1 your super right renesmee has to be cgi
renesmee has to be cgi!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
renesmee has to be 100% cgi
renesmee cgi renesmee cgi renesmee cgi renesmee cgi renesmee cgi renesmee cgi renesmee cgi renesmee cgi reneswmee cgi renesmee cgi reneswmee cgi renesmee cgi renesmee cgi
your right renesmee cgiiiiiiiii
renesmee has to be cgi
renesmee is going to be cgi like it or not so get on with it because she is going to be cgi
renesmee cgi cgi cgi
renesmee is going to be 100% cgicgicgu
I THINK 4 THE SAKE OF MANY OF MY FRIENDS IT WOULD BE EASIER 4 THEM IF SHE IS CGI – THE JELOUSY CAN GET PRETTY INTENSE LOL BUT SPEAKING 4 MYSELF IM A TEAM CULLEN ALL THE WAY AND DONT EVEN THINK I CAN COPE WITH A REAL ACTRESS PLAYING THE OLDER RENESMEE SO WHOOP WHOOP CGI!!!
Oh my goodness! an amazing article. Thank you!
“custom t shirts…
Thanks for this article
After reading this I thought it was informative , i appreciate you taking the time and effort to put this posts.
Helpful info discussed I am really pleased to read this particular post..many thanks with regard to providing all of us nice information.Great walk-through. I truly appreciate this article.
I appreciate the insightful post. Thanks.
Waiting for your next post!!
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>